Finished Kasane's route last night. I'm going to add this to the end of my review as well, but wanted to post it separately so it would come up on the feed in case anyone had any input on the stuff I'm about to say.
Kasane's Route-Specific Stuff:
-The story was messy, way messier than Yuito's. I knew to expect "big reveal" stuff sooner, but the overall presentation of the story was nooootttt great, missing great chunks of storytelling that was present in Yuito's route, and just overall not a full story. The story is this game already has problems, but it was just terribly executed with her route, and makes it obvious that Yuito is the true protagonist. Definitely do not recommend playing her route first for this reason alone, but also because...
-Playing as Kasane was, for me, mostly miserable. She uses SIX KNIVES CONTROLLED BY HER PSYCHOKINESIS and she STILL MISSES CONSTANTLY. She's more suited for aerial combat for whatever reason (apparently) but fighting flying enemies was a pain in the ass because she missed constantly. Howwwww? I would be right on them doing nothinggg. Her movements are way more fluid and graceful than Yuito, but I hate that her strong attack is a backstep. She's weaker and has less defense, so even though I had already played through the game once at this point and knew how to fight everything, knew which powers were effective, knew how to use combo visions, etc., she was still getting WRECKED by monsters FORTY LEVELS LOWER in the early game (since this was NG+ and I started at level 60), and was barely doing damage to them. It was insanely frustrating. I'm sure there's more of a learning curve with her, and yeah I got more used to using her as I progressed, but it was never as fun or effective as fighting with Yuito. Maybe I just suck, and I admittedly don't play games with this sort of combat often, but honestly, I know I'm not that bad.
If I had chosen to play as Kasane first and had tried to struggle through this game without being overleveled...? I probably would have never finished this game.
Now for all of the questions that I still have because the story did not do a good job of answering them, or just created stupid plot points. I'm just going to put them all in spoiler tags:
1. Why the fuck is Karen--not quite the main antagonist, but eventually kind of is--doing all of this to save Alice, who was FUBUKI'S FIANCE, while Fubuki is like ENTIRELY UNBOTHERED BY IT ALL? This bothered me endlessly through both playthroughs. FUBUKI lost his fiancé, not stupid-ass Karen with his stupid-ass name, and yet Karen is the one off time-traveling a billion times and then erasing himself completely to "save" Alice. This makes no sense and I almost feel like it was a translation error. Sure, he can love his best friend's fiance, I guess, but Fubuki is always otherwise shown as a decent, kind man, and he somehow never acknowledges like any of this situation.
2. Karen "sacrificing himself" by erasing his existence is what brings Alice back, and everyone else in the world forgets him except the main party and Fubuki because they were there and attached via SAS for the time-travelling. This is just so stupid. It makes no sense. Why would that even need to be what has to happen? Why were all of his attempts to save her even failures? How hard was it to go back to the mission she got turned into an Other on, NOT do that mission, and be fucking done with it? Fuck. Bamco is becoming obsessed with someone sacrificing themselves for no reason and that's becoming one of the weakest parts about Tales games. I'm getting sick of those endings.
3. The endings. They're basically the same, which is fine. Kasane wants to go to the moon to help the people there now that the Extinction Belt is gone, and see how they've been faring for the past 2000 years. This is true in both endings. In Yuito's ending, he's going to retire soon because he's "going to lose his powers eventually." This goes against everything Yuito. It makes no sense. Also, Yuito 50 years in the future still had powers, so why the hell is he even stressing? In Kasane's route, he does NOT mention retiring; he just says he thinks he'll stick around the OSF for a while since he plans to straighten out the world while she works on the moon.
4. Yakumo Sumeragi. Okay, so Karen went back in time, killed Yakumo and took his place. Yakumo is Yuito's ancestor. After the final fight, Yuito thinks, "Does that make Karen my ancestor?" Unlikely, BUT, it does make one wonder, where the fuck was Yakumo's family? He obviously had one to begin the whole Sumeragi line on Earth. There was mention of his "personality changing" which we know is when Karen replaced him, but did his family never see his face again at that point? Was he already old, wife dead, kids grown? Like, how did any of that work out?
5. Karen meeting Yakumo-Karen. That scene still just...what? Shiden said, "None of this makes sense to me." Same.
I think there were other things that I can't remember now, and I think it's safe to say the story was fine overall, but there were definitely unanswered questions that should not be left to the anime (if that's what's happening, because I dunno, I haven't watched any of it) or something else, and could have been addressed organically in the game. It was poorly executed at times and I think they were trying too hard to include some things that did not need to be included, but the ideas themselves were good.
I would play a sequel, but after I go do some grinding to get the last trophy for finishing the Brain Map, I don't think I'll be revisiting this game. There's not really any post game and I don't see any replay value in it.