I've played through this more times than I care to admit, but I finally settled on five solidifed playthroughs/characters, one for each route (including the love triangle option).

All the usual selling points of Choice of Games/Hosted Games titles are here - massive amounts of player choice, diversity, character customisation, fun stats.

The four love interests are varied enough in personality, though my opinion on them is coloured by the later developments in each romance; it's difficult for me to stick purely to Book One in my thoughts here.

The Wayhaven Chronicles is a good choice of CoG game if you're interested in a more typical YA-style vampire/supernatural romance; although you play as a detective, I wouldn't go for this purely for the mystery/detective work aspect, because there really isn't a lot of it in this one.

I admit I mostly like this series for Mason.