I mean it. This is the best Paper Mario game. Anyone who thinks Thousand-Year Door is better either hasn't played it in a long time or is afraid of new things.*
Ok, let's start out by addressing the elephant in the room. Like the previous two entries in the series, this is not an RPG. You do not level up in the traditional sense. The combat is different. However, and I'll only say this once: if you are the type of person that judges a game (or anything, for that matter) for what it's not, rather than what it is, you have bad opinions. Fight me.
I'm just gonna repeat what I said about Sticker Star's combat, because the same pretty much applies:
"It's not so much that the battle system sucks. In fact, by the end of the game, I didn't mind it too much; ... to be honest I genuinely liked it during boss battles. Again, it's not so much that it sucks, it's just that it's pointless. Other than coins ... there's rarely much of a reward for going into battle. The result is a game where I'm constantly running away from battles because they're a nuisance."
The difference is that the puzzle-based system in Origami King is actually really cool. Two of the trophies required to 100% this game have you playing mini games where you're just solving the puzzles without the combat, and it makes you realize how much fun those puzzles actually are. It's just that, I don't want to be doing puzzles every time I enter combat. They're either too easy, and thus a nuisance, or too hard, and thus frustrating. However, like in Sticker Star, you can normally just run away from enemies before you enter combat, and I really didn't mind the number of mandatory battles.
Boss battles, however, are freaking awesome. I won't waste time describing it; just go watch a video if you don't know how it works by now. I'll just say that every single boss battle was a joy, and replaying them with increased difficulty for one of the trophies was challenging and entertaining.
Ok, so aside from the weird battle system. what else are we working with? Just an absolutely incredible game in every single category. Graphics? Beautiful. Music? Pure happiness. Gameplay? Out of this world.
Ok, the reason I think the old-school Paper Mario games aren't as good as they seemed when we were kids is because they are so extremely linear. Now don't get me wrong, there are times when I got frustrated at Origami King for not letting me go where I wanted, especially at the beginning, but there are so many large open areas in this game that you actually get to take at whatever pace you choose. At one point you're basically just playing The Wind Waker. In a Paper Mario game. It's incredible!
I'm actually amazed at what they packed into this game. After the first streamer, I thought each world or area or whatever was going to be pretty formulaic. Boy, was I wrong. Every streamer is loosely broken up into two parts: getting to the dungeon/temple place, and doing the dungeon/temple place. But this looks completely different for every streamer. One level has you solving ancient puzzles in a desert before navigating an underground ruin, while another has you sailing the ocean before conquering a tower. Still another takes place in a spa in the clouds before entering Bowser's castle. The variety and zaniness of the story rivals that of Thousand-Year Door, while the puzzles and exploration seem straight out of a Zelda game. And it all takes place in a world that you can easily navigate and return to through Toad Town.
Would I like to have a Paper Mario game that goes back to its RPG roots? Yes. Do I miss partners that you could control in combat? Sure do. Would Origami King be better with those things? Absolutely. Is it a bad game because it's missing those things? Heck freaking no. Absolutely take off with that idea. Don't let nostalgia blind you to a masterpiece when it's right in front of you waiting to be enjoyed. This is an incredible game.
Go. Be free of your nostalgia goggles. Try new things. Enjoy this game. If you don't, you are a bad person.*
*lol jk everyone's opinions are valid.
UPDATE: I just figured out why I think this game is the best in the series. While other games had things I like more, every other game also had things I disliked. This game really didn't. I didn't dislike anything about this game, which was a first for Paper Mario.