
The Wolf Among Us was about as close to an earned purchase as it gets for me. By that I mean a game that I’ll buy based entirely on the quality of a previous game. The most automatic reputation purchases I’ve ever made were both this year, for Dark Souls II and Transistor. Dark Souls and Bastion were so amazing …
Read more

The Wolf Among Us was about as close to an earned purchase as it gets for me. By that I mean a game that I’ll buy based entirely on the quality of a previous game. The most automatic reputation purchases I’ve ever made were both this year, for Dark Souls II and Transistor. Dark Souls and Bastion were so amazing that I was willing to throw their developers cash based solely on the trust that their new project would be excellent as well. I was willing to the the same with The Wolf Among Us based on a brief glimpse at the premise and my enjoyment of The Walking Dead: Season 1.
The character development, storytelling, and drama of TWD all in a modern Fables setting? Yes please! Having picked up The Walking Dead after all five episodes had been released, I was looking forward to experiencing The wolf Among Us as it was intended, one episode at a time. Having now experienced episodic games in both ways I can say this with impunity: Unless you have friends that will spoil the plot for you or you’re a VERY patient person, just wait.

I’m a good friend, so these screenshots will be as spoiler free as possible.
Based purely on the story and gameplay experince I thought The Wolf Among Us was very good, but allow me first to share some advice for Telltale Games and any other episodic game developers out there.
Dear Telltale,
How are you? It’s hell of a game you made there! It didn’t quite live up to TWD Season 1, but almost nothing ever will. Great job! I really love how well you understand pacing. It is because I know you understand story pacing that I find it inexcusable that you released the 2nd episode of The Wolf Among Us almost 4 MONTHS after the 1st.
Now I know you were busy at the time. You released the 1st episode of The Walking Dead: Season 2 in that time and you also are presumably working on your new Game of Thrones and Borderlands series’ as well. You know who doesn’t care how busy you are? The people who bought The Wolf Among Us. That’s who. This brings me back to story pacing. You might have been able to get away with a 4 month gap between episodes 4 and 5 because by that point I’d have been invested in the story. What you can’t do is introduce players to a brand new story and set of characters for 2 hours and then ask them to wait the equivalent of an entire NFL season for the next installment.

I got two oil changes for my car between the release of Episode 1 and 2.
We’re not a captivated audience yet, Telltale Games. We don’t have the attachment for these characters that we had for Clem and Lee. It will get there, but you have to take us there. The most committed of us either read a recap or (like me) played the first episode over again just before the 2nd episode was released. We’re not going to do that every time. Luckily you released your next episodes in 2, 1 1/2, and 1 1/2 months respectively, but for some the damage was already done.
I beg you, Telltale, if you ever find yourself in this position again, either delay the start of The Walking Dead: Season 2 (unlikely) or do your best to make the larger gaps towards the end of the series when most of your audience is already invested in the characters and story.
Keep making great games, and I’ll be sure to keep buying them. Although next time I’ll probably wait and buy them when they’re all out and on sale.
All the best,
Tarfuin.
Seriously, this was everyone’s reaction to TWAU Episode 2

All that aside, the game really was exceptional. Having never read the Fables graphic novel series, I found myself immediately immersed in the setting. I love the idea of all these fables forming together to try to assimilate into modern society. More than that though, I couldn’t get enough of seeing the humanized interpretations on some of the fairy tale characters. There’s one in particular that is absolutely perfect on so many levels. In the interest of keeping this spoiler free I’ll just say he owns a club. You’ll know him when you see him.
The investment in the characters is there after a few episodes. It doesn’t have the natural protective relationship that TWD had with Lee and Clem, but if anything that makes your decisions even more murky. In TWD I would always ask “What’s best for Clem?” as a moral fallback. You don’t have that here. The decisions are truly yours.

My favourite screenshot by far.
I absolutely recommend this game to everyone, especially if you’re either a fan of Fables/fairy tales or the first season of The Walking Dead game. If you’re the type that needs to know the story right away, the game was well worth a Day 1 pickup, but you need to exercise patience. In all, I think your best bet for any of Telltale’s games are to wait until Episode 3 is released and pick it up on sale. You’ll have time to play the first three episodes with just a bit of a gap before Episode 4 comes out. Then you’ll have a nice, small, hype-building gap before finally enjoying the finale.
Read less