Main game
3.47 average rating based on 294 ratings
Y'know. This game could have been good. It was originally an adaptation of Franz Kafka's The Castle, with Shinji Mikami and SUDA51 leading the show. It had actually started development. Design docs exist clearly showing what the game was supposed to be. The game was called "Kurayami".
Then EA got involved.
And what we have instead is a childish, foul-mouthed game for morons where your main weapon is called the "Boner" and sexual assault jokes and alcoholism are apparently really funny.
Most insultingly, this game uses assets made for Kurayami. I am more familiar with concept art for that game than for Shadows of the Damned. And it was evidently far enough along that they used work from Kurayami on this shitshow. A similar mechanic using darkness and shadows is included too.
I bought Shadows of the Damned more to see how much of Kurayami was left than for the game itself. I expected maybe a fun, stupid game with some relics of the old work... But I got something more akin to watching someone defile a corpse.
This game has a forced radio buddy. It has juvenile pee-pee jokes. It has the 2010 ideal of "cool". It …
Y'know. This game could have been good. It was originally an adaptation of Franz Kafka's The Castle, with Shinji Mikami and SUDA51 leading the show. It had actually started development. Design docs exist clearly showing what the game was supposed to be. The game was called "Kurayami".
Then EA got involved.
And what we have instead is a childish, foul-mouthed game for morons where your main weapon is called the "Boner" and sexual assault jokes and alcoholism are apparently really funny.
Most insultingly, this game uses assets made for Kurayami. I am more familiar with concept art for that game than for Shadows of the Damned. And it was evidently far enough along that they used work from Kurayami on this shitshow. A similar mechanic using darkness and shadows is included too.
I bought Shadows of the Damned more to see how much of Kurayami was left than for the game itself. I expected maybe a fun, stupid game with some relics of the old work... But I got something more akin to watching someone defile a corpse.
This game has a forced radio buddy. It has juvenile pee-pee jokes. It has the 2010 ideal of "cool". It also has a couple of nobody producers from EA putting their names in equal billing with Akira Yamaoka and Shinji fucking Mikami.
And you could say, "Maybe this is what Mikami and SUDA wanted." Perhaps. But SUDA's games, while sometimes vulgar and try hard, are rarely this obnoxious. And usually they have a point to make behind all the nonsense. And then I look at Overstrike - sorry, "FUSE" - a game that very well could have been Overwatch before Overwatch existed, only to have EA forcibly turn it into a miserable army shooter for depressed single dads. No fun allowed. That heady adaptation of an existentialist classic novel? Add more dick jokes and take out all that nerd shit. We here at EA know what the gamers really want.
Fuck this game. 🖕
Play Killer Is Dead instead. That game has its dumb moments, but it was actually a great game with an interesting story and themes.
It's a bit rough around the edges, but what Shadows of the Damned lacks in finesse, it more than makes up for in creativity. Like Suda51's other games, this one is somewhat niche, but if you are a fan of Resident Evil, Silent Hill, Killer7, or No More Heroes, you owe it to yourself to check it out. It's like a smoothie of all of those things, a bizarre concoction that bears the fingerprints of not only Suda, but Shinji Mikami and Akira Yamaoka, who also contributed their respective talents to the project. Steering away from full-on horror into tongue-in-cheek grindhouse territory, it is every bit as fun and stupid as the movies it tries to emulate. Add that to some of the most bizarre imagery and great music found in any game of the time, and you have something that feels like a forgotten cult classic of the genre. It's unfortunate that this game, like many Japanese-developed games of the 7th Generation, were heavily tampered with by western publishers (In this case EA), leading to a final product that didn't completely capitalize on the potential of this team-up of survival-horror masters.
Replayed with the Hella remastered edition. It did not age as well.
Hot damn. They released a remaster just a few days ago without anyone noticing, it seems (not even grouvee's/giant bomb's database). And apparently it's good?