Playing a Super Mario game always feels like the franchise building upon what came before it, but with Super Mario 3D World, Nintendo seems to be celebrating every Mario game that came before. Especially over the last few years, with games like Super Mario Odyssey and The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, Nintendo has really given their all in their games, while honoring the series up to this point. This is why Super Mario 3D World is a fitting Wii U game to make the move to the Switch: you can see the fingerprints of every prior Mario game all over this one.
Super Mario 3D World's primary DNA seems to come from the overworld of Super Mario 3, and the level inventiveness of Super Mario Galaxy. But this truly does feel like an amalgamation of Mario's history. There's the option to play as the other main Mario characters, like in Super Mario Bros. 2, or the same character movements that were introduced in Super Mario 64, albeit in a more controlled environment. Yet even though Super Mario 3D World is so much about the past, it's wild how fresh and new this all feels.
I had played Super Mario 3D World back when it came out on the Wii U, and replaying it this time around, I kept thinking just how truly insane how many times Nintendo has completely broken new ground with Mario, both in terms of technical evolution and in overhauling what these games actually are. No matter how this series changes though, Mario always manages to fit like a glove. Controlling these characters always feels smooth, there's a comfort and reward to completing a level, and despite having decades of experience with this franchise, Mario games remain challenging.
Every level in Super Mario 3D World is like a little puzzle to crack, an opportunity to show your skills in this series. In addition to beating each level, there are also three stars to find and a stamp hidden in almost every level. This is a game that wants you to explore everything it has to offer, and is remarkably rewarding for those who want an extra challenge. Even on my second time around with this game, I found myself impressed by how intuitive and smart and innovative this feels, and how absolutely mindblowing it is that Mario has broken new ground like this over and over.
In addition to wanting an opportunity to play Super Mario 3D World again, I also picked this up for the new challenge of Bowser's Fury, which I felt might be a hint at what's to come for this franchise. Bowser's Fury is open world in a way that we really haven't seen from Mario games before. There's no breakdown of each different section, but instead, the entire world is visible from the very beginning. The scale is sort of surprising, and can at times feel a bit daunting. I don't mind bigger Mario worlds, but not having it split up into different fragments almost felt wrong for this series.
Especially after playing Super Mario 3D World, I found aspects of Bowser's Fury to be sort of clunky. The attempt to find all of the game's secrets could be daunting, especially when you're relying on the timed appearances of Bowser to find them, and the exploring of the actual world wasn't always as smooth as I would've hoped. I don't know if it was the game or my controller drifting, but I kept having extreme camera problems throughout that made this frustrating to control.
As I said before, Super Mario 3D World felt like the entirety of Mario's history in one game, but Bowser's Fury specifically reminds me of Super Mario Sunshine, for better and for worse. Setting the entire world as a series of islands is sort of obnoxious, especially since most people seem to not care about the series' water levels anyways. And while the idea of centering this game around gigantic Godzilla-esque fights between Mario and Bowser that scale this entire world map, I never felt like this concept was as interesting as it was on paper.
At the very least, I will be extremely interested to see if the ideas of Bowser's Fury are integrated into future Mario games. With a bit of polish, this could be a very cool concept, but it just never quite worked for me as much as I would've liked.
Still, this is a great collection for the Nintendo Switch, especially for those wanting a Mario fix between Super Mario Odyssey and its sequel. Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury is a charming, smart, and often extremely difficult game that is also an extremely fun reminder of just how revolutionary this series has been for so long.