Now, I know. I KNOW. The millions of expansions. The obvious cashgrabs. The Sims 4 invites understandable frustration from the people trying to break their way into the system. EA is, of course, a hellish corporation. We are on the same side.
Let's take a step back. The Sims 4 was released in September of 2014. Since that date, the very same game has recieved 10 years worth of updates alongside 10 years of expansions. When I first played TS4 in 2014, it felt barren, empty and strangely polished. Nobody was certain where this venture was headed, and many returned to the highly developed TS3 instead. For those of us who waited, we hankered for the thing which would eventually invite the game's most damning criticism: the expansion pack.
Fast forward to March 2025. TS4 has four different types of purchasable content: expansions, game packs, kits and stuff packs. Expansions introduce new worlds and central mechanics which change the way the game is played, in addition to new content. Game packs are similar, but considerably smaller in scope, and the same can be said for kits. Stuff packs only introduce game items.
Are these additions overpriced? Absolutely. Yet are they also nigh impossible to compare to other in-game purchases? Absolutely. With each new game-changing expansion, each add-on interact seamlessly with every other possible combination of game mechanics one might have. Adding livestock to the game isn't just a question of how sims might interact with them, but a question of how they interact with dogs, cats, seasons and rentals. With all the expansions considered, the game reaches a level of complexity that I have never seen any other game come close to. What's more, with the base game often popping up for free, the expansions are the product, and they are best enjoyed one by one.
Now comes the time for full transparency. I own all of the Sims 4 content, save for 5 game packs which I find annoying, 3 stuff packs and almost all of the kits (I have never paid full price for any of these). I also have 1,400 hours in this game. The decade that I have spent playing TS4 has been bumpy, frustrating, and genuinely fulfilling. This game is its own artform, in a way, honing visual creativity and narrative storytelling, and I can say with complete honesty that there remain many, many things I am yet to have experienced. What's more, I am glad about the expansion packs.
"Glad about the expansions? The microtransactions?! Are you crazy? And you call yourself a communist?" Well, to start with, I don't agree with the 'microtransactions' label on TS4 - there is no way to pay for limited or temporary resources. Everything you buy, you own. At the end of the day, I can sell my EA account for quite a sum if I were to decide to give TS4 up for good. Additionally, the truth is that, within our capitalist hell, these expansions enable genuinely passionate creators to continue working on the game, long after its release. There is no MMO, nor pay to win in TS4, and within TS4 social communities, creating builds and sims with limited packs is unique, appealing and interesting content. The target audience for extortionate prices are hobbyists with disposible income, not socially dependent addicted players.
This game has indeed been growing alongside players for ten whole years. Trans sims, polyamorous sims and two whole new life stages are all now part of the base game. On the ten year anniversary, the team finally patched in a way to label sinks, so that sims would stop going to wash up plates in the bathroom. It's a small example of the kind of perpetual improvement this game would not have were it not financially lucrative.
I love The Sims 4. I love creating stories. I love creating legacy games, and watching adult sims move through the world while I remember when they said their first words. I love building places for my sims to live, and I love when things go wrong. My save file is a personally constructed exercise in understanding how people's lives can turn out so differently.
So, should you go grab all of the expansions right now? No, of course not. But if you wait for a sale, and free up some hard drive space, you might find yourself taking a first step into a genuinely incredible world. Ah, wait - still no cloud saves? Fuck it. 1 star.