I had never played any entry of Uncharted. I got the collection as a present and decided to just start with the first one. Reviews contains minor spoilers (about gameplay parts) I didn't blot out. Major spoilers I did.
Narrative
The story is about Nathan Drake, following a trail left by his ancestor Francis Drake towards El Dorado, the supposed city of gold. To finance this trip he pretends to do this for a tvshow and Elena, the journalist/camera girl is on this journey filming it. They are on a ship, which gets blown up by pirates and after this the story begins on an island with a ruin. By finding old tombs, buildings, unraveling mysteries, doing puzzles and shooting baddies we try to find the lost treasure of El Dorado.
At first Drake, and his buddy Sully leave Elena on some island and take their own boat to find the treasure. Then sully is shot and Elena tracks Drakes movements and they try to find the treasure.
The story was fine. The lore was pretty interesting, and I was definitely interested I finding out what happened to El Dorado and the spaniards that tried to find the treasure. Character development was pretty much non-existent. Drake was Drake throughout, a witty adventurous son of a bitch. The only thing really happening to him is he at first doesn't respect Elena, and then he does, because she turns out to be pretty badass. Of course they totally fall in love as well. The characters however are all likable, the badguys are assholes, and the banter between main characters was enjoyable. Writing was pretty good.
Gameplay
It's basically a third-person shooter with a few puzzles in it. I didn't know much about this game beforehand so I was expecting the other way around. It consists of doing some puzzle, climbing or otherwise, to get to a place. Get a wave of badguys, get a story tidbit, and repeat. There is not much more to it than that. The gunplay was not terrible, not great. I had weird moments where drake would make weird movements and get shot, baddies die and fly off anywhere, as well as their gun (which you want to pick up ammo). Cover system was basic, sometimes hard to change cover as it wasn't always clear where Drake would decide to go. I did play on easy, I don't think I'd want to deal with the clunkyness on harder difficulties.
The puzzles were extremely easy. The climbing puzzles extremely frustrating. It was rarely clear where to go, what things were climbable and not, I've jumped to my death numerous times. I really hope this gets better in the next games, because some parts I was so frustrated (Church) I rage quitted.
Then there are the "chase" parts. The first one in a jeep, which is fine. Not much to say about that. But there is two bits where you have to drive around on a jetski. You have Elena with you who can shoot. Most annoying though, you can't do both at the same time. Well, you can but she won't aim for the enemies lol. You have to drive, stop and shoot. Drive, stop and shoot. It turns from a high speed chase, into a annoying dumb part that I hated. The second time this happens, you have to go upriver as well, so if you don't keep driving you float back. There is exploding barrels you need to avoid, and people to shoot. Where the first time Elana had a shotgun, now she has a measly handgun which means most enemies have to be shot multiple times, unless you can aim, which I can't do very well with a controller heh (even then, a lot of enemies have helmets now which means you still need to shoot multiple times usually). These parts were just awful.
Finally the final boss was very stupid.
Setting
This was the remastered version of the game, and I thought it looked pretty good for its age. The tropical island, lost city environments looked interesting and detailed. I did get that mystery/creepy vibe from them. The various dungeons are creepy as well. In terms of looks I thought the levels were pretty good. It's just very hard sometimes to know where to go. The artstyle is otherwise not very interesting so got not much more to say about it. Animation shows it's age, especially when descending stairs.
Music I barely remember, not much to say about it. It fits the setting, but was not memorable.
Other
No crashes in this game, but some weird physics bugs where drake does some weird dancing. The AI of the enemies also did some weird dancing sometimes. Nothing really bothersome.
Conclusion
I enjoyed playing this game in the end, otherwise I would not have finished it. The story was enjoyable, the characters were likable. Not many terrible bugs, just some crazy physics stuff sometimes. Gameplay shows it's age. Gunplay clunky at times, climbing puzzles pretty abysmal if I'm being honest. I was hoping there would be a bit more balance between puzzles/shooting, as shooting was definitely the bigger part of the game. Not sure if I would recommend it though. Not to busy people at least, there is better games to play. But if you have nothing to do some weekend, and you have this already lying around, why not, give it a go.