I expected to love the game because I liked Morrowind quite a lot back in the day, and once upon a time had enjoyed playing Daggerfall, and also quite enjoyed Fallout 3 & New Vegas. It's a solid title, holds up to Bethesda's reputation, and is a great step forward in the Elder Scrolls franchise. Even for a several-years-old game, …
Read more
I expected to love the game because I liked Morrowind quite a lot back in the day, and once upon a time had enjoyed playing Daggerfall, and also quite enjoyed Fallout 3 & New Vegas. It's a solid title, holds up to Bethesda's reputation, and is a great step forward in the Elder Scrolls franchise. Even for a several-years-old game, the graphics have held up quite well, and the sound design is good too.
The downsides: some of the writing is excellent - immersive and engaging - but some of it feels like standard fantasy boilerplate. At times the side quests seem like just filler to waste my time. At other times they steal the show and make the world worth exploring. So with such a massive amount of content I find myself picking and choosing which content to complete more than I normally would in an open-world game (I am typically a completionist). Some of the quests were oddly written, with conclusions that make the player feel railroaded into completing them a certain way when there's an obvious alternative solution that just hasn't been written in as an option. I feel like the standard in RPG writing is a bit past that at this point.
The narrative suffers from the main problem in any game which lets the player create their own character: the main character itself lacks character or a true place in the world. Some other titles (like Mass Effect) have handled this slightly better, making the craft-your-own-hero thing work a little better, and sadly I don't think Skyrim did that very well. In Skyrim, if you want to feel like your character belongs and has a place in the game world, you've got to do the mental legwork yourself and create the story in your own headcanon. Otherwise you're just "generic fantasy adventurer hero".
Read less