Review WolfSpirit292 3/5 · Jul 16, 2026
Nice continuation of the series
For fans of Frogwares' Sherlock Holmes series that were disappointed by the open world of Sherlock Holmes Chapter One, you should appreciate this return to a linear story. I personally liked the open world, but... Also, there's not really any combat in this one (a couple instances of firing a gun under very specific circumstances), which I know is another …
For fans of Frogwares' Sherlock Holmes series that were disappointed by the open world of Sherlock Holmes Chapter One, you should appreciate this return to a linear story. I personally liked the open world, but... Also, there's not really any combat in this one (a couple instances of firing a gun under very specific circumstances), which I know is another thing some people didn't care for.
The mechanics are familiar while also changing things up a bit (for an overall improvement). I really enjoyed how they handled combining clues this go around. Rather than the usual "match two things" that are even in the "classic" games, there could be a number of things, spanning different categories, in order to find a proper deduction. There are a number of dots to each deduction, and they're color coded by type of clue, which makes everything a little easier to pick up.
While the game is mostly linear, there are a few small side cases you can pick up in the various locations. The story takes us from London to the U.S. and back again. The locations themselves are stunning. Atmosphere is also played well, from music to the lighting to the design of a space. Voice acting and character design was A+.
Even though this is a direct sequel to Chapter One, you don't have to have played it in order to enjoy this one. Again, I realize the open world might have put some people off. That said, this still won't be for everyone due to its obvious cosmic horror bent. Which it does very well I should say. In the end, this game does mystery and deduction right, which is really where Frogwares shines.