Review KillahMonk 3/5 · Jan 24, 2026
Brilliant Foundations, Showing Its Age
Super Mario 64 still holds up surprisingly well, especially in its core mechanics. Its art style is unmistakably Mario, and the movement system remains tight, expressive, and skill-based. Even today, controlling Mario feels good in a way many modern games still struggle to match.
As the quintessential 3D platformer, SM64 is built around patience and precision. The game often asks …
Super Mario 64 still holds up surprisingly well, especially in its core mechanics. Its art style is unmistakably Mario, and the movement system remains tight, expressive, and skill-based. Even today, controlling Mario feels good in a way many modern games still struggle to match.
As the quintessential 3D platformer, SM64 is built around patience and precision. The game often asks the player to master difficult jumps, camera management, and awkward angles. While this design can be rewarding, it can also be obtuse and frustrating, especially by modern standards. Some challenges feel less like deliberate tests of skill and more like fights against the camera or unclear level design.
The game’s main strength is its focus on gameplay above all else. Mario feels athletic and acrobatic, and each level functions as a sandbox meant to test your understanding of movement. Experimentation and mechanical mastery are constantly encouraged, and at its best, the game delivers a unique sense of accomplishment that few platformers can replicate.
That said, Super Mario 64 offers very little beyond its mechanics. The lack of a meaningful story or environmental storytelling feels like a missed opportunity, especially given the variety and creativity of its levels. While this minimalism was understandable at the time, it does make the experience feel somewhat hollow compared to later entries or other Nintendo franchises like Zelda, which I personally prefer for their stronger narrative focus.
Overall, Super Mario 64 is a historically important and still enjoyable game, but one that clearly shows its age. It’s absolutely worth playing today—especially via the PC port with 60 FPS, 4K textures, and quality-of-life improvements—but it’s no longer the untouchable masterpiece it once was. Instead, it stands as a strong foundation for the genre rather than its definitive peak.
